New York City5-4
FT
TorontoT. Castellan... 38'
Thiago Andra... 49'
S. Rodriguez 54'
K. Parks 58'
Gabriel Pere... 75'
13' J. Jimenez
27' J. Jimenez
86' D. Kerr
90' M. Bradley
New York CityToronto
Apr 2, 2022
Toronto FC
2 - 1
Aug 8, 2021
Toronto FC
2 - 2
May 15, 2021
New York City
1 - 1
Oct 28, 2020
Toronto FC
0 - 1
Sep 23, 2020
New York City
0 - 1
Mar 7, 2020
Toronto FC
1 - 0
Oct 23, 2019
New York City
1 - 2
Sep 11, 2019
New York City
1 - 1
Mar 30, 2019
Toronto FC
4 - 0
Aug 12, 2018
Toronto FC
2 - 3
Jun 24, 2018
New York City
2 - 1
Jul 30, 2017
Toronto FC
4 - 0
Jul 19, 2017
New York City
2 - 2
Nov 6, 2016
New York City
0 - 5
Oct 30, 2016
Toronto FC
2 - 0
May 18, 2016
Toronto FC
1 - 1
Mar 13, 2016
New York City
2 - 2
Sep 16, 2015
New York City
2 - 0
Jul 12, 2015
New York City
4 - 4
Jun 20, 2015
Toronto FC
0 - 2
