May 30, 2016
AFC Wimbledon
2 - 0
Apr 9, 2016
Plymouth
1 - 2
Aug 8, 2015
AFC Wimbledon
0 - 2
Apr 14, 2015
Plymouth
1 - 1
Oct 21, 2014
AFC Wimbledon
0 - 0
Apr 21, 2014
Plymouth
1 - 2
Dec 29, 2013
AFC Wimbledon
1 - 1
Feb 26, 2013
AFC Wimbledon
1 - 1
Oct 6, 2012
Plymouth
1 - 2
Mar 6, 2012
AFC Wimbledon
1 - 2
Aug 16, 2011
Plymouth
0 - 2